| I am a great complainer that bears the name of Christ | 141 Complainer |
| I am a poor wayfaring stranger | 457 Wayfaring Stranger |
| I am a stranger here below | 317 Jackson |
| I am on my journey home. | 425 Golden Streets |
| I began life’s journey when young | 227 Ode of Life’s Journey |
| I beheld, and lo a great multitude, which no man could number | 250 Heavenly Vision |
| I came to the place where the lone pilgrim lay | 341 The Lone Pilgrim |
| I cannot bear Thine absence, Lord | 520 Ata |
| I find myself placed in a state of probation | 179 The Christian Warfare |
| I have my troubles here below | 465 Where There’s No Trouble and Sorrow |
| I heard a great voice from heav’n saying unto me | 320 Funeral Anthem |
| I know that my Redeemer lives | 277 Antioch |
| 468 Soul’s Delight |
| I’ll sing my Savior’s grace | 416 The Christian’s Nightly Song |
| I love my blessed Savior | 109 Carnsville |
| I love Thee, my Savior; I love Thee, my Lord | 525 Imandra |
| I love to see the Lord below | 265 Gwehelog |
| I’m dying, Mother, dying now | 398 The Dying Boy |
| I’m enlisted on the road | 294 Rocky Road |
| I’m not ashamed to own my Lord | 73b Arlington |
| 74t The Enquirer |
| I’m tired of visits, modes and forms | 55 Converse |
| I need God’s blessings while I live | 389 Fredericksburg |
| I sing the mighty pow’r of God | 244 Plevna |
| I soon shall view the promised land | 548 Wootten |
| I’ve a long time heard that there will be a judgment | 567 The Great Day |
| I’ve learned to sing a glad new song | 530 A Glad New Song |
| I want a sober mind | 455 Soar Away |
| I want to go to heav’n, I do | 568 I Want to Go to Heaven |
| I want to live a Christian here | 406 New Harmony |
| I would see Jesus when the flow’rs | 75 I Would See Jesus |
| If angels sung a Savior’s birth | 273 Milford |
| 453 Newbury |
| In grandeur see the royal line | 526 Schwab |
| In humble notes our faith adores | 351 Pittsford |
| In mercy let me live in peace | 347b Humility |
| In the beginning was the Word | 553 Anthem on the Beginning |
| In the bright season of thy youth | 176b Blooming Youth |
| In the cross of Christ I glory | 532 Peace and Joy |
| In the floods of tribulation | 145b Sweet Affliction |
| In those days came John the Baptist, preaching in the wilderness, crying with a loud voice, saying | 572 The Lamb of God |
| In those days came John the Baptist, preaching in the wilderness of Judea | 232 Baptismal Anthem |
| In vain we lavish out our lives | 180 Vermont |
| Increase, O Lord, our faith and hope | 471 Becket |